8 Best Toro Lawn Mower Replacement Blades to Buy in 2025

Uncompromising in its design, this genuine Toro tooth mulcher blade is the gold standard for owners seeking factory-perfect results. Its standout feature is the aggressive tooth design, specifically engineered to shred grass clippings into an ultra-fine mulch that nourishes your lawn. This blade directly addresses the common frustration of clumping and visible thatch, ensuring a clean, professional finish that aftermarket options strive to replicate.

In real-world testing, the blade’s performance is exceptionally balanced, minimizing mower vibration and delivering a consistently level cut across dense turf. With a precise length of 21-11/16″ and a sturdy 0.150″ thickness, it fits perfectly on compatible 22″ Recycler decks without any modifications. It excels in typical residential conditions, turning both overgrown grass and fallen leaves into a fine, almost invisible compost, though it isn’t designed for clearing heavy brush.

This blade is the ideal choice for the Toro owner who prioritizes guaranteed compatibility and peak mulching performance above all else. While an aftermarket option like the MaxPower 331376B offers a similar profile, it may not have the exact same balance and steel composition as this OEM part. The genuine Toro 59534P blade provides peace of mind and the exact performance your mower was designed to deliver.

Delivering exceptional value, this two-pack from UDC Parts is a formidable contender for budget-conscious homeowners. The blades feature a Gator-style mulching design with high-lift teeth, aiming to replicate the performance of premium options at a fraction of the cost. This set directly solves the problem of high seasonal maintenance costs by providing a ready-to-go spare, ensuring you’re never caught with a dull blade mid-season.

During testing, the slightly wider 2-1/2″ blade width created noticeable lift, which is beneficial for pulling up matted grass for a more even cut. The 0.149″ thickness is comparable to OEM standards, providing adequate durability for residential lawns with varied conditions, from thin grass to thick patches of clover. The blades handle typical yard debris well, though the steel may require more frequent sharpening than a genuine Toro blade to maintain its edge.

This UDC two-pack is tailor-made for the pragmatic homeowner with a compatible 22 inch Toro Recycler who values having a backup on hand. It provides a significant cost advantage over purchasing two separate OEM blades. Compared to the single Grasscool blade, this UDC pack offers superior long-term value by including a second blade for future use.

Engineered for dependability, the Grasscool two-pack offers a robust solution for maintaining a pristine lawn throughout the mowing season. These blades are marketed as commercial mulching blades, featuring a toothed design that excels at chopping clippings multiple times before they hit the ground. For homeowners battling thick leaf coverage in the fall or rapid spring growth, this design significantly reduces clogging and improves lawn health.

In practice, these blades prove to be workhorses. With a substantial thickness of 5/32″ (0.156″) and a length of 21-5/8″, they feel solid and resistant to bending on uneven terrain. The air lift of 7/8″ is effective at standing grass up for a clean, uniform cut, and the mulching performance is impressive, leaving behind minimal visible debris. The paint coating wears off quickly as intended, revealing a serviceably sharp edge.

The ideal user for this Grasscool two-pack is the diligent homeowner who mows often and wants a durable, cost-effective replacement with a spare at the ready. The value proposition of getting two blades makes it a smart seasonal purchase. Placed against the Apeixoto 2-Pack, the Grasscool blades offer a slightly thicker, more traditional design focused on durability.

This single blade from Grasscool is an efficient and straightforward Toro lawn mower replacement blade for when you need a quick fix without committing to a multi-pack. It features a proven toothed mulching design intended to deliver a clean cut and effective recycling of grass clippings back into the lawn. It perfectly solves the immediate problem of a bent or severely dulled blade, getting your mower back in service affordably.

On a standard residential lawn, the blade performs its duties admirably. The specifications—21-5/8″ length and 2-1/4″ width—are a near-perfect match for many 22″ Toro Recycler decks, ensuring a balanced and vibration-free operation. While it provides a satisfactory cut on moderately thick grass, its edge retention may not match that of premium, heat-treated steel blades, potentially requiring a mid-season touch-up.

This blade is the perfect choice for someone needing an economical, no-frills replacement for a single damaged blade. It provides core functionality and a decent mulching cut for those who don’t require the longevity or guaranteed fit of an OEM part. Compared to the genuine Toro 59534P, the Grasscool blade offers a compelling value proposition for those prioritizing budget over brand assurance.

Delivering precision and reliability, the MaxPower 331376B stands out as a top-tier aftermarket blade that proudly meets or exceeds OEM specifications. Manufactured in the USA, this blade is engineered to be a direct, high-quality substitute for the original part, instilling confidence from the moment you unbox it. It solves the common concern among buyers that aftermarket parts might not match the fit, finish, and balance of the original.

In the field, the blade’s performance is virtually indistinguishable from a stock blade. Its 21-23/32″ length and 7/16″ center hole ensure a perfect, secure fit on compatible Toro mowers, eliminating guesswork and installation headaches. The powder coating protects the blade in transit and wears away to reveal a precision-sharpened edge that provides a crisp, clean cut right from the start, handling thick grass with authority.

This MaxPower blade is for the discerning homeowner who seeks OEM-level quality without the associated cost. It represents a smart upgrade from generic budget blades and a worthy alternative to the genuine article. When compared directly to the Toro 59534P, the MaxPower blade offers a nearly identical performance profile, making it a superior value choice.

This specialized two-pack is the perfect solution for owners of Toro 21″ Heavy-Duty or Super Recycler mowers, a category often overlooked by generic replacement blades. Its key feature is the unique spiral-shaped design, which is engineered for maximum air lift and suction, making it highly effective for both bagging and mulching. It solves the critical problem of finding an exact-fit, high-performance blade for these specific, premium Toro models.

With an exact length of 21 inches and a 0.43″ center hole, these blades are not interchangeable with their 22″ counterparts, highlighting the need to verify your model number. In use, the high-lift design excels at pulling grass blades upright for a perfectly uniform cut, and it significantly improves bagging efficiency, reducing the chance of leaving stray clippings behind. The heavy-duty steel construction feels robust and ready for demanding use.

This set is exclusively for owners of compatible 21″ Toro mowers who demand a precision cut and superior bagging performance. The value of receiving two blades makes it a practical choice for seasonal replacement. Unlike the toothed blades for 22″ models that prioritize fine mulching, this blade’s spiral design focuses on powerful lift, offering a different kind of cutting performance.

Offering an aggressive mulching action, this two-pack of Apeixoto blades is designed for homeowners who want their grass clippings to virtually disappear. The defining feature is the two sets of serrated teeth, which work to re-chop clippings inside the deck for an exceptionally fine mulch. This design directly tackles the issue of clumping, especially in damp or overgrown conditions, promoting a healthier, cleaner-looking lawn.

During operation, the mulching capability is immediately apparent. The blades, measuring 21-15/16″ in length, spin up smoothly and create powerful airflow thanks to their 2-1/8″ width. The serrated edges make short work of leaves and standard grass, dicing them into tiny pieces that quickly settle into the turf. This enhanced chopping action makes it a strong performer for homeowners who exclusively mulch.

This Apeixoto blade set is ideal for the mulching enthusiast with a 22″ Toro Recycler who wants the absolute finest clippings to feed their lawn. The inclusion of two blades provides excellent value for a full season of pristine lawn care. When compared to the UDC Parts 2-pack, the Apeixoto’s serrated design provides a more specialized and aggressive mulching action.