7 Best Replacement Craftsman Lawn Mower Wheels 2025

Engineered for superior grip, the CRAFTSMAN CMXGZAM325070 immediately solves the frustrating problem of lost traction on challenging lawns. Its standout feature is the aggressive tread pattern, designed to bite into turf, grass, and even damp hills where other wheels would slip. This isn’t just a simple replacement; it’s an upgrade, thanks to a durable 1.25-inch oil-impregnated copper steel bushing that ensures a smoother, more durable rotation than standard plastic hubs.

In real-world testing, these 8-inch front-wheel-drive replacements transform a mower’s handling on uneven terrain. We found they significantly reduce slippage when navigating inclines or making tight turns on wet grass, a common failure point for OEM wheels. The robust construction instills confidence, whether you’re using them on a walk-behind mower, a snow blower, or an edger, proving their versatility across different equipment and seasons. While they excel on turf, the aggressive tread might be slightly less smooth on perfectly flat pavement, a minor trade-off for their primary function.

When positioned against more universal options like the 72-108 wheels, the CRAFTSMAN CMXGZAM325070 offers a specialized solution focused purely on performance and longevity. While the 72-108 provides versatility for grills and wagons, this CRAFTSMAN wheel is the ideal choice for homeowners who demand uncompromising traction and a durable build specifically for their lawn equipment. For those prioritizing grip over all-purpose utility, the CMXGZAM325070 delivers a more robust and reliable performance than its budget-friendly counterparts.

Delivering an exceptional balance of compatibility and performance, this two-pack of 583719501 front wheels is a lifesaver for owners of self-propelled mowers with worn-out drive gears. The design precisely integrates 53 gear teeth, ensuring a perfect mesh with the mower’s drive system to restore its self-propel functionality instantly. Made from a high-density plastic and premium rubber composite, these wheels are built to address the common pain point of stripped or broken original parts without a hefty investment.

During our evaluation, the installation was straightforward on a compatible Craftsman walk-behind model, immediately bringing the front-wheel-drive system back to life. The 8-inch diameter and 1-3/4-inch width match OEM specifications perfectly, preventing any operational wobble or misalignment. The wheels provided consistent traction across a standard suburban lawn, handling both flat stretches and minor grades with ease. They effectively replicate the performance of original parts, making them a reliable and practical repair solution.

Compared to the brand-specific CRAFTSMAN CMXGZAM325070, this 583719501 two-pack offers a much wider range of compatibility for Husqvarna, Poulan, and other brands at an often more accessible price point. While the CRAFTSMAN wheel focuses on an upgraded, aggressive tread, this option prioritizes restoring original functionality for a vast number of specific self-propelled models. It represents a fantastic value for anyone needing a direct, no-frills replacement to get their mower moving again.

Masterfully tackling the challenge of worn or damaged rear mower wheels, this 490-324-0002 replacement set provides a robust, oversized solution for larger walk-behind mowers. Their defining characteristic is the solid, puncture-proof construction, eliminating the risk of flats that can plague air-filled or weaker plastic tires. The large 12-inch diameter offers superior stability and a smoother ride over bumpy, uneven ground, making yard work noticeably less jarring.

In practice, the bar tread pattern on these 12-inch by 1.7-inch wheels delivers solid, dependable traction without being overly aggressive on delicate turf. Each tire’s 50 lb. load rating speaks to its durability, capably handling the weight of heavier mower models from brands like Craftsman, Honda, and Troy-Bilt. The installation is simplified with included offset adapters and spacers, allowing for a customized fit on various axle setups. These wheels are built for endurance, not just a quick fix.

Unlike the smaller, 8-inch front-drive wheels in this list, the 490-324-0002 set is specifically designed for the rear axle, offering size and strength where it’s needed most. While the CRAFTSMAN CMXGZAM325070 excels at front-wheel grip, these rear wheels provide the foundational stability and durability for the entire machine. For users with larger mowers needing a heavy-duty rear wheel upgrade, this set offers a more specialized and resilient solution than standard 8-inch universal replacements.

Revitalizing gear-driven mowers is the core strength of the Budrash 180775 front wheels, designed as a precision replacement for a wide array of popular models. The critical feature is the 53-tooth gear integrated into the hub, which engages seamlessly with the mower’s self-propel mechanism to restore lost power. This two-pack is the perfect remedy for the common issue of stripped plastic gears, instantly turning a frustrating push mower back into an effortless self-propelled machine.

Putting these wheels to the test, the 8 x 2-inch dimensions and 1/2-inch bore proved to be an exact match for a compatible Craftsman 917 series mower. The black rubber tread provides reliable traction for everyday mowing conditions, from dry patches to moderately thick grass. The hub’s 1-9/16-inch length ensures a snug fit on the axle, eliminating the wheel wobble that often accompanies worn-out original parts. The installation is quick, requiring only a wrench to get your mower back in action.

The Budrash 180775 serves a nearly identical function to the 583719501 wheel set, as both feature the crucial 53-tooth gear design. The key differentiator often lies in their specific compatibility lists and slight variations in material feel. The Budrash wheels are an ideal choice for owners of the specific Craftsman, Husqvarna, and Poulan Pro models listed, offering a direct and dependable fix. It provides a comparable performance to other gear-driven replacements, making it a strong contender based on availability and specific model matching.

Precision-engineered for a perfect fit, the 634-05040 wheel replacement set is the definitive choice for owners of specific modern Craftsman, Cub Cadet, and MTD mowers. Unlike universal wheels that can be hit-or-miss, these are designed as a direct OEM replacement, eliminating guesswork and ensuring flawless compatibility. Their primary benefit is restoring the smooth, stable operation of your 21-inch self-propelled mower just as the manufacturer intended, solving issues of wobble or poor fitment from generic parts.

In a hands-on scenario, these 8-inch wheels slide onto the axle of a compatible Craftsman M215 with factory-level precision. The assembly feels solid and secure once the mounting nut is tightened, with no play or looseness. On the lawn, they deliver a smooth, consistent roll that enhances the mower’s maneuverability and overall feel. This set is less about upgrading traction and more about restoring the original performance and stability of your machine with a part you can trust.

When compared to the highly versatile 72-108 universal wheels, the 634-05040 wheels offer a trade-off: you sacrifice broad applicability for a guaranteed perfect fit on a targeted list of models. While the 72-108 can be adapted to various equipment, this set is for the user who wants to avoid any potential installation headaches and maintain their mower’s original specifications. It provides a superior fit and finish for its intended models over any one-size-fits-all solution.

Embodying true versatility, the 72-108 Universal Wheels from Oregon are the ultimate utility player for home and garden equipment repairs. Their biggest strength is their incredibly broad compatibility, designed to fit not just Craftsman and MTD mowers but also Radio Flyer wagons, BBQ grills, and hand trucks. This adaptability makes them a fantastic item to have on hand for quick fixes, solving the problem of finding a specific wheel for older or obscure equipment. The diamond tread pattern provides a good balance of grip and low rolling resistance.

During use, these 8-inch wheels prove to be a reliable, no-fuss solution. With a standard 1/2-inch bore and 1-3/8-inch hub length, they fit a wide range of axles with minimal to no modification needed. While the plastic construction is standard, it’s durable enough for light-to-medium duty on mowers, carts, and grills. The wheels roll smoothly on both grass and hard surfaces, and the diamond tread offers a noticeable improvement in grip over completely bald, worn-out tires.

The 72-108 wheels stand in stark contrast to specialized options like the CRAFTSMAN CMXGZAM325070. While the CRAFTSMAN wheel is a performance upgrade with its aggressive tread and copper bushing, the 72-108 is a pragmatic, multi-purpose replacement. It is the ideal choice for someone who needs a functional, affordable wheel that can serve multiple roles around the garage. For general-purpose repairs, this wheel offers far greater flexibility than any model-specific replacement.