8 Best Toro Lawn Mower Wheel Replacement Options 2025

Delivering an uncompromising factory-fresh fit, the Genuine Toro OEM 140-2358 wheels are the definitive replacement for specific 22-inch Recycler mowers. These are not just generic replacements; they are engineered with the original skid-resistant tread and durable hard plastic and molded rubber composite that your mower came with. This ensures that the front-wheel-drive system engages perfectly, restoring lost traction and maneuverability on inclines and wet grass.

In real-world testing, these 8-inch wheels demonstrate superior grip and an exact fit that third-party options often struggle to replicate. The Front Wheel Drive specific design means the internal gears mesh flawlessly, translating into smooth, consistent power delivery without slipping or grinding. Whether navigating tight corners or powering through thick patches of lawn, the performance is identical to a brand-new machine, a crucial factor for maintaining the efficiency of models like the 21442 and 21472.

For owners prioritizing originality and guaranteed performance, these Toro OEM wheels are the clear choice. While the CheeMuii 119-0311 wheels offer a more budget-conscious alternative with broader compatibility, they lack the precision engineering and material assurance of a genuine Toro part. The Toro OEM 140-2358 provides peace of mind and longevity, making it the superior investment for maintaining your mower’s peak operational condition.

Offering a remarkably accessible solution, the CheeMuii 119-0311 wheels provide a functional and affordable replacement for a vast range of Toro mowers. Built from a blend of high-quality plastics and rubber, these wheels are designed to resist friction and aging, directly addressing the common issue of worn-out, cracked original wheels. Their main appeal lies in their extensive compatibility list, making them a go-to option for owners of popular models like the 20330 and 20370.

During hands-on use, these 8-inch wheels install easily, with a 1/2-inch bore and 3/4-inch hub offset that matches many Toro front-drive mowers. While the tread pattern is more basic than some premium options, it provides adequate traction for typical residential lawns with moderate slopes and dry conditions. The plastic gear engages reliably with the mower’s drive system, restoring self-propel functionality for a fraction of the cost of OEM parts.

These wheels are ideal for the homeowner seeking a quick, cost-effective repair without needing manufacturer-grade components. Compared to the Genuine Toro OEM 140-2358, the CheeMuii wheels trade brand assurance for versatility and savings. If you need to get an older mower back in service without a significant investment, the CheeMuii 119-0311 delivers outstanding value.

This set of 8″ Front Drive Wheels emerges as a powerful value proposition for Toro owners, blending wide compatibility with a performance-focused design. The standout feature is the robust, 53-tooth plastic gear that ensures a positive and secure engagement with your mower’s self-propel mechanism. This design directly combats the common failure point of stripped gears, promising renewed pulling power and a longer service life for your 22-inch Recycler.

In practice, these wheels deliver a noticeable improvement in traction on varied terrain. The 2-inch width and aggressive tread pattern help the mower grip firmly on damp grass and uneven ground, situations where worn wheels typically spin out. Installation is a breeze; the 1/2-inch bore and 3/4-inch hub are dimensionally accurate for models like the 20330 and 20371, allowing for a quick, hassle-free swap that gets your machine running in minutes.

Targeted at the DIY-savvy homeowner, this set offers a fantastic balance of performance and affordability. Unlike the Budrash 105-3036 rear wheels, which feature a metal gear for heavy-duty rear-drive systems, these wheels use a high-quality plastic gear optimized for front-wheel-drive efficiency. This set represents a significant upgrade over worn-out stock wheels without the premium expense of OEM parts.

Engineered for maximum durability, the Budrash 105-3036 wheels are a purpose-built solution for Toro’s rear-drive Recycler mowers. Their most critical feature is the integrated metal drive gear, a significant upgrade over the standard plastic gears found on many replacement wheels. This robust construction is designed to withstand the high torque and stress of rear-wheel-drive systems, preventing premature wear and tear on models like the 20041 and 20066.

On the lawn, the difference is tangible. The 8-inch wheels, with their 1-3/4-inch hub offset, provide excellent stability and the tough tread pattern grips tenaciously, especially when mowing uphill or through dense turf. The metal gear ensures a slip-free power transfer from the axle to the wheel, restoring the mower’s self-propel system to its original, powerful state. This targeted design makes them a superior choice for mowers that do heavy lifting.

The Budrash wheels are the perfect choice for users whose mowers have previously suffered from stripped plastic gears. While the HQPASFY 105-1816 offers a larger 12″ diameter for enhanced stability on rough terrain, the Budrash focuses on powertrain longevity with its metal gear. For anyone with a compatible rear-drive Toro, these wheels offer a more resilient and long-lasting repair.

Transforming your mower’s stability on challenging terrain, the HQPASFY 105-1816 rear wheels are a heavy-duty upgrade for select Toro 22″ Recycler mowers. Their defining characteristic is the large 12-inch diameter, which provides a significant advantage in navigating bumpy, uneven, or rutted lawns. This increased size allows the mower to glide over obstacles that would bog down standard 8-inch wheels, resulting in a smoother cut and less effort from the operator.

In performance scenarios, the robust tread pattern provides exceptional grip, enhancing control and maneuverability on slopes and slippery surfaces. The 2-inch width and 1/2-inch center hole ensure a secure, OE-like fit on compatible models such as the 20016 and 20019, restoring the mower’s original stance and performance characteristics. This heavy-duty design is built to withstand the rigors of frequent, tough mowing tasks without compromise.

These wheels are tailor-made for users with large or imperfect lawns who need maximum stability. In contrast to the 8-inch Budrash 105-3036 wheels, which prioritize gear durability, the HQPASFY wheels focus on improving the mower’s handling and ride quality. If your primary frustration is getting stuck or scalping high spots, this 12-inch wheel set is the superior solution for a smoother mowing experience.

Specifically designed to revitalize your push mower, the 115-4695 rear wheels offer a precise and economical replacement for a range of 22-inch Toro Recyclers. These wheels feature a hard plastic drive gear with 38 teeth, engineered to perfectly match the specifications for models like the 20332 and 20334. The primary benefit is restoring smooth rolling and proper alignment to mowers where the original wheels have cracked or worn down, making mowing a physical chore.

In use, these 8-inch wheels prove to be a lightweight yet sturdy solution. The tough tread provides reliable traction for a push mower, preventing slipping on gentle inclines or damp spots. With a 1/2-inch bore and 1-3/4-inch hub offset, installation is straightforward, allowing you to quickly replace a damaged wheel and get back to maintaining your lawn with renewed ease and efficiency.

This set is the ideal choice for owners of non-self-propelled Toro mowers who need a reliable, no-frills replacement. Unlike the Antanker 105-1815 wheels, which are built with a 53-tooth gear for self-propelled systems, these are optimized for push models, ensuring they roll freely without unnecessary drive-train resistance. For a simple push mower repair, this product provides an exact-fit solution at an excellent value.

Breathing new life into classic machines, the Antanker 105-1815 front drive wheels are a savior for owners of older Toro Recyclers. Their key strength is the targeted compatibility with models from the early 2000s, such as the 20001 and 20072, which can be difficult to find parts for. Featuring a 53-tooth gear and a radial tread design, these wheels are engineered to restore lost traction and bring dormant self-propel systems back to full functionality.

In field tests on an older Toro mower, these 8-inch wheels provided a dramatic improvement in pulling power. The gear assembly meshes cleanly with the mower’s axle, and the tough tread grips effectively, allowing the machine to climb hills and power through thick grass as it did when new. With a 1-3/4-inch hub and 1/2-inch bore, the fit is precise, ensuring no wobble or alignment issues after installation.

These wheels are the perfect solution for anyone trying to extend the life of a reliable, older Toro mower. While the Sutmorly 11″ wheels offer a universal fit for various brands, the Antanker wheels provide a guaranteed, model-specific fit that eliminates the guesswork and potential need for spacers. For reviving a trusted machine, this targeted replacement offers superior performance and reliability.

Delivering unmatched versatility, the Sutmorly 11″ rear wheels are a universal solution designed to fit a wide array of walk-behind mowers from brands like MTD, Craftsman, and Toro. The main advantage here is flexibility; the kit includes plastic spacers and metal washers to adapt the 1/2-inch nylon hub to various axle lengths. This makes it a one-size-fits-many repair kit, perfect for mowers with hard-to-find or discontinued parts.

The performance of these wheels is defined by their durable, puncture-proof construction. As solid plastic wheels, they eliminate the risk of flat tires, and the 11-inch diameter helps the mower roll more smoothly over rough patches and small obstacles. Each wheel boasts a 60 lb. load rating, ensuring they are robust enough to handle the weight and stress of regular mowing on most residential self-propelled or push mowers.

This kit is ideal for the user with multiple mower brands or one who is unsure of the exact part number needed. In contrast to the Genuine Toro OEM 140-2358 wheels, which offer a perfect but highly specific fit, the Sutmorly wheels prioritize broad compatibility over precision. If you need a durable, adaptable wheel that can get almost any compatible mower rolling again, this universal set is an excellent and practical choice.