8 Best Craftsman Lawn Mower Rear Wheel Replacement Options 2025

Delivering a cost-effective OEM solution, the Craftsman 584465301 rear wheel is an excellent choice for a quick and reliable repair without overspending. As a genuine American Yard Products part, it provides the assurance of correct fitment for a specific range of Craftsman, Husqvarna, and Poulan mowers. This 8-inch by 1.75-inch wheel is a direct replacement, designed to solve the immediate problem of a broken or worn-out wheel with minimal hassle.

During use, its performance is identical to the original factory wheel, offering balanced handling on typical suburban lawns. The plastic construction is solid, and the tread pattern provides adequate grip for standard mowing conditions, from damp grass to dry, dusty patches. Its straightforward design means installation is a breeze, often taking just a few minutes with a simple wrench. However, it’s important to note that this is a single-wheel purchase, so if both rear wheels are worn, you’ll need to order two.

This wheel presents a clear trade-off when compared to the 2-pack 72-108 Wheels from Oregon. The Craftsman 584465301 offers a guaranteed OEM fit for its intended models, whereas the Oregon wheels provide universal compatibility for various equipment at a lower cost per wheel. The Craftsman is perfect for the user needing a single, precise replacement for a supported model. For those needing to replace just one wheel on a budget, this part offers better value than purchasing a full set you don’t need.

This 2-pack of 490-324-0002 replacement wheels offers a transformative upgrade for many walk-behind mowers, especially those struggling on rougher terrain. The standout feature is the large 12-inch diameter, which provides a smoother roll over bumps and divots compared to standard 8-inch wheels. Made from solid, puncture-proof material with a bar tread pattern, these wheels are designed to enhance traction and durability, directly addressing the common issue of worn, slipping tires.

In practice, these wheels make a noticeable difference in maneuverability, especially on sloped or uneven yards. The 1.7-inch width and 50 lb. load rating per tire ensure stability, and the included spacers and washers help achieve a secure fit on various mower brands, including Craftsman. Installation is simple, but the universal design may require using the included adapters to get the offset just right. The solid construction means you’ll never have to worry about a flat, though it offers less cushioning than a pneumatic tire.

When positioned against a single OEM part like the Craftsman 532433121, this kit’s value proposition is clear: you get two larger, more robust wheels for a comparable investment. This is the ideal choice for users looking to improve their mower’s performance on challenging lawns, rather than just restoring it to factory condition. For those wanting an upgrade in size and durability over a simple stock replacement, this 12-inch wheel kit is a superior choice.

Engineered for longevity, this 2-pack of 12-inch replacement wheels is a fortress of durability for your lawn mower. The key selling point is its robust, broad-shouldered design made from puncture-resistant materials, built to withstand harsh conditions that would shred lesser wheels. This solid construction completely eliminates the risk of flats, solving a major headache for those who mow in areas with thorns or sharp debris. The kit’s universal compatibility makes it a versatile solution for numerous brands, including Craftsman.

On the lawn, the 12-inch diameter provides a significant advantage in navigating uneven ground, while the solid tire construction ensures consistent performance without maintenance. Each tire supports a 50 lb. load capacity, making them suitable for heavier walk-behind mowers. The included plastic spacers and metal washers are crucial for a wobble-free installation, though you’ll need to carefully select the right combination for your specific model’s axle.

This kit’s focus on durability sets it apart from more basic replacements like the Craftsman 584465301. While the OEM wheel guarantees a perfect fit, this aftermarket kit offers a tangible upgrade in toughness and resilience. It’s the perfect choice for homeowners with demanding yards or anyone tired of dealing with wheel damage. The value here lies in its build quality, offering a more permanent solution than a standard plastic replacement.

The Sutmorly 12-inch rear wheel kit emerges as a remarkably versatile and affordable alternative to pricey OEM parts. Designed as a direct replacement for part number 490-324-0002, this 2-pack offers broad compatibility across a huge range of brands, making it a go-to solution for many mower owners. Its primary appeal is the combination of solid, puncture-proof construction and a complete installation kit, providing everything needed for a quick and effective repair.

In real-world mowing, these 12-inch wheels glide over uneven terrain more easily than smaller factory wheels, reducing the effort needed to push the mower. The tread offers reliable grip, and the durable plastic material is designed to outlast standard-issue wheels. The included spacers are essential for adapting the 1/2-inch nylon hub to various axle lengths, ensuring a snug fit. This thoughtful inclusion of hardware simplifies what can otherwise be a frustrating installation process with universal parts.

Compared directly to the genuine Craftsman 532433121, the Sutmorly kit provides a pair of larger, more robust wheels for a significantly lower investment per wheel. While the Craftsman part guarantees a perfect, out-of-the-box fit for specific models, the Sutmorly wheels are for the user who wants an economical upgrade in both size and durability. This kit offers superior overall value for anyone comfortable with a universal-fit product.

Unleashing unparalleled versatility, the 72-108 replacement wheels from Oregon are the ultimate multi-purpose solution for far more than just your lawn mower. Their standout feature is the incredibly wide compatibility, designed to fit not only Craftsman and MTD mowers but also wagons, grills, and hand trucks. The diamond tread pattern on the black rubber provides enhanced grip and quieter operation compared to standard hard plastic wheels, solving the problem of poor traction and noise.

In testing, these 8-inch wheels prove to be a capable replacement for stock mower tires, with a 1-3/8″ hub length and 1/2″ bore that fit many common axles. The 1-1/2″ offset hub is a critical detail for ensuring proper alignment on mowers. Beyond the lawn, their utility shines, easily swapping onto a Radio Flyer wagon or a BBQ grill for improved mobility. This jack-of-all-trades design makes them a fantastic item to have on hand in any workshop.

This wheel’s universal nature contrasts sharply with the specific fit of the 734-2010 Replacement Wheel Assembly. While the 734-2010 is tailored for certain Cub Cadet and MTD models, the Oregon 72-108 is for the user who values flexibility and multi-use potential. For anyone needing a reliable 8-inch wheel for various pieces of equipment, this 2-pack offers unbeatable utility and value.

This 734-2010 replacement wheel assembly is a precision-engineered solution for owners of specific Cub Cadet, MTD, and Craftsman mowers. Its greatest strength is its exact compatibility with models like the Cub Cadet SRC621, providing a fit and function that universal wheels often can’t match. Made from high-quality PVC material, these wheels are designed for maximum durability and traction, directly addressing the need for a reliable replacement on self-propelled models where grip is critical.

With a diameter of 8.66 inches and a width of 1.39 inches, these wheels restore the mower’s original handling characteristics and stability. The installation process is exceptionally simple for compatible models—just unbolt the old wheel and slide the new one on the axle. This hassle-free, direct-fit design is a significant advantage for users who want to avoid the trial-and-error of spacers and adapters common with universal kits.

When compared to the highly versatile Oregon 72-108 wheels, this 2-pack is far more specialized. The Oregon wheels fit a vast array of equipment, while the 734-2010 assembly excels by providing a perfect, factory-spec fit for a narrower list of mowers. This makes it the ideal choice for owners of compatible models seeking to restore their machine’s performance without compromise. Its value is in its specificity, offering a better-than-universal fit for those it’s designed for.

Boasting a truly all-terrain design, this universal 12-inch wheel kit is built to conquer challenging mowing environments. The upgraded PU plastic material and mixed-pattern tread are its defining features, providing superior grip and shock absorption compared to standard wheels. This design directly solves the problem of mowers slipping on wet grass or struggling over roots and rough patches, offering a significant performance boost.

In the field, the 1.75-inch width creates a stable base, while the solid, puncture-proof construction ensures you can mow with confidence. The included bearings, bolts, and nuts make this a comprehensive upgrade kit, allowing for a smooth roll and secure installation on everything from Craftsman mowers to generators and garden tillers. The high resilience of the PU material helps absorb impacts, reducing vibration and prolonging the life of the wheel and the machine.

This kit’s performance focus puts it in a different class than a standard OEM replacement like the Craftsman 584465301. While the Craftsman wheel restores original factory function, this 12-inch kit elevates the machine’s capability, making it better suited for varied terrain. It is the perfect choice for users who need more than just a replacement and are looking to enhance their equipment’s traction and stability.